South River Boat Rentals and Sailor For Hire
In
Annapolis, we rented a sailboat from South River Boat Rentals ($400) and hired an
instructor (who turns out to be Captain Rich from Sailor For Hire --- $200.) We'd been
looking forward to this experience for months, poring over our sailing
book, and getting ready to learn to sail on a real boat. Too
bad it was such a big disappointment.
Griff seemed to be the
guy in charge at South River Boat Rentals. He was the one who
picked up the phone when I made my reservation three months ago, the
one who assured me all was well when I called to check in a week
before, and the one who had a brand new jeep when we came back from our
day on the water. I had explained to him that Mark and I were as
raw as beginners get, and I took his advice to rent a 26 foot Hunter,
even though I could have gotten a 24 foot Rainbow for $150 less.
I'm still not sure if that piece of advice was greed on Griff's part or
was actually based on his knowledge, but the new jeep makes me lean
toward the former.
I
think that Griff holds some of the blame for our bad day on the
water. Not only did he hire an instructor who turned out to be a
dud (more on that later), he also didn't warn us that the wind was
really too high for beginner instruction. When Mark asked for
Griff's opinion on what kind of day it was for sailing, Griff said it
was a solid 10 out of 10. In retrospect, I think that Griff is
like many young men who like speed and excitement; otherwise, telling
people who had never sailed that it was a good sailing day with a
forecast of gusts above 30 knots seems like negligence. On the
bright side, Griff did let us take out the 33 foot Hunter at no
additional charge --- evidence, perhaps, that he had some idea that it
was too rough for us out there?
Enter Captain Rich. To
be fair, I think that Captain Rich might have just been the totally
wrong captain for us --- he runs a business as a private instructor, so
clearly he must not rub everyone the wrong way. That caveat
aside, he made our first sailing lesson extremely unpleasant.
Captain Rich was clearly tense about the high winds, and he barked
orders at us as if we were deckhands rather than paying customers, not
giving us time to even follow his orders before berating us. He
also called Mark "Hercules" the whole time, with a bit of a sneer in
his voice that got my dander up.
I
can just hear you saying. "Forget whether he was pleasant.
Was he a good teacher?" Knowing what I know now about the lay of
the land, I would have set up the lesson completely differently than he
did. We were docked in South River (more of a bay than a river),
which runs down for at least six miles before reaching the Chesapeake
Bay. Although the winds weren't low in South River, they also
weren't the absurdly crazy winds we felt when we popped out into the
bay...right in the middle of a morass of crab pots. Captain Rich
had to keep the motor on (and yelled at us a lot) to keep the boat from
tangling in the crab pots or capsizing in the wind, and in retrospect I
wonder why we even went out into the bay? I suspect Captain Rich
would have been bored running up and down South River, but it would
have been more our cup of tea --- and I was careful to explain to him
at the beginning that we were raw beginners, that our goal was to
learn. Zipping out into the dangerous bay just to take a picture
of us in front of a lighthouse proves to me that Captain Rich either
wasn't listening to our needs, or didn't care about them.
That lapse in judgement
aside, I felt like Captain Rich was too impatient to be a good
instructor. He seemed far less interested in letting us learn to
sail than in getting
where he was going. Even near the end when Mark seemed to be
getting
his sea legs, Captain Rich kept barking orders, grabbing the wheel, and
not letting Mark make
the mistakes beginners have to make in order to learn.
The real problem was
that Captain Rich was a bad communicator, and sailboats require perfect
communication between the captain and crew. Near the end, Captain
Rich had finally taken us back into the river, and Mark was at the
helm, tacking back toward port. A bit of harmony began to prevail
on the boat, because Mark took the communicator role on himself
(although I think it should have been the captain's duty.) When
Captain Rich barked an order, Mark made sure to not only answer that he
had heard it, but also to maintain a running dialogue on what he was
doing to achieve the desired goal. Maybe if we'd learned that
coping mechanism from the beginning, we wouldn't have been yelled at
all day.

I'm ashamed to admit
that around the middle of the afternoon, I was done dealing with
Captain Rich and I just tuned out. This was the best part of the
day for me --- I closed my eyes, ignored unpleasantness, and just
imagined what it would be like to have this sun, wind, and water around
me on our own terms. If it hadn't been for this bit of peace, I
probably would be typing right now that I will never go sailing again.
Mark's
excitement helped him ignore the nastiness, so he kept sailing.
We were in the South River, and I could tell that Mark was starting to
really get a handle on the boat, but Captain Rich spoiled even
that. "We're barely making any headway upwind," he growled
impatiently, kicking on the motor. Couldn't he see that it was a
big accomplishment for Mark to be controlling the boat on his own with
a 20 knot wind? Who cares if we were making much headway?
Despite bad weather and
problematic instruction, I did get a lot out of our day on the
water. I got a feel for how to jibe, to tack, to pull on the
sheets, how to furl and unfurl the jib. But I won't be going back
to South River Boat Rental, and I recommend that other beginning
sailors find someone else to teach them to sail.
Want
to be notified when new comments are posted on this page? Click on the
RSS button after you add a comment to subscribe to the comment feed.
Everyone seems to agree with you that barking orders is pretty much par for the course (although I think there's a difference between a captain and an instructor --- the instructor should try to do more than just bark orders.) You'll see in Mark's post tomorrow that his thicker skin let him shrug off more of the day.
The more I think about it, the more I think that the weather was the real problem, and maybe we just had ourselves to blame. We looked at the weather forecast, saw "windy", and thought that was a good thing, but in the future we'll try to keep our plans a bit more flexible so we can sail in easier weather at first.
The bigger boat did make frequent jibing a bit safer. Like the other boats out that day, we didn't even put the mainsail up, and the boat was so big that when the jib jibed, it didn't come anywhere near us.
Amy --- I think you're right that starting with something smaller and safer is a better start. I like the idea of being somewhere that it's not so dangerous to be out by yourself, so you can make mistakes and really learn.
Kelly Jo --- I really appreciate you saying that about barking orders. That was my gut feeling too --- that an instructor shouldn't just be yelling at us. I was feeling a bit burned out by the experience, but Mark talked me into going out again more locally in an easier setting so that we can, hopefully, put a better taste in my mouth!